The Indispensable Role of Quality Control and Supervision in an AI-Driven Patent World

Ian Schick
6 July 2023

With the proliferation of generative artificial intelligence (AI), the legal profession is experiencing a paradigm shift that is significantly impacting traditional patent practices. AI technology, with its remarkable computational and analytical capabilities, is automating the document production process, reshaping the patent law landscape, and introducing cost-efficient and swift solutions. However, the rise of automation in the legal profession has also brought forth a new and invaluable service: Quality Control and Supervision (QC&S).    

Human supervision, with its ability to ensure the accuracy, reliability, and legal validity of AI-produced patent documents, is turning into a potential game-changer. The QC&S of these AI-generated documents is becoming a critical function that law firms can offer, creating a robust new revenue stream that could help redefine their roles and value in the rapidly evolving legal industry.    

The Imperative Need for QC&S    

The integration of AI into patent practices is transforming the industry, enhancing efficiency, and enabling law firms to manage larger workloads effectively. Despite these benefits, the technology isn't foolproof. Just like with a junior associate attorney, instances of errors, misunderstandings of legal nuances, or inaccuracies in patent applications can happen in AI systems.    

Even the most advanced AI technologies can struggle to replicate human understanding of complex legal language and subtle intricacies inherent in the patent process. Patent documents often contain subtle nuances, references, and contexts that could be overlooked or misinterpreted by an AI system. This dichotomy between AI's processing power and the inherent complexities of the patent law underscores the need for human oversight and control to ensure the reliability, accuracy, and legal validity of AI-generated patent documents.    

QC&S: A New Revenue Frontier for Law Firms    

Law firms stand at a unique crossroads, with an opportunity to harness their legal acumen and industry expertise to create a new revenue model. They can provide QC&S services that include reviewing, amending, and validating AI-generated patent documents. This additional layer of human validation not only ensures the accuracy of AI-produced documents but also delivers added value to clients, assuring them that the patent documents produced are not only time and cost-efficient but also reliable and accurate.    

Here's a detailed look at how this new profit center can shape up:    

1. Document Review and Amendment    

One of the primary services under the QC&S umbrella would be a meticulous examination of AI-produced patent documents. Attorneys can leverage their expertise to identify and correct any errors or inconsistencies, whether in factual details, legal arguments, or omissions in the document.    

This layer of review and amendment extends beyond simple error-checking. It also includes analyzing the contextual accuracy of patent documents. For instance, AI may not fully understand the application of an invention within a particular industry, missing out on key technical details or misinterpreting technical jargon. Lawyers, with their deeper understanding of the industry and legal landscapes, can spot these inaccuracies, ensuring that patent applications accurately reflect the intended purpose and scope of the invention.    

2. Legal Validity Checks    

Another vital aspect of QC&S is ensuring the legal validity of AI-generated patent documents. This process involves making sure that all documents align with the patent laws and regulations of the relevant jurisdictions. Legal professionals can cross-check legal references, verify the accuracy of patent claims, and ensure the appropriate usage of legal terminologies.    

For instance, the wording and structure of patent claims can significantly impact the scope of the protection afforded by the patent. An AI system might generate a technically accurate patent claim, but without understanding the legal implications, the claim may be overly broad or narrow. Lawyers can refine these claims to better align with the client's protection strategy and increase the likelihood of patent grant.    

3. Client Customization    

Providing QC&S services also allows law firms to offer client-specific customization for AI-produced patent documents. This customization can include adjusting the document's structure, language style, or specific patent claim strategies. By tailoring the AI-generated output to meet a client's specific needs or preferences, law firms can add a personalized touch that AI systems may struggle to replicate.    

For instance, a client might have a specific patent prosecution strategy that they prefer, such as pursuing narrower patent claims to increase the likelihood of a patent grant or opting for broader claims for more extensive protection. A lawyer, through the QC&S process, can customize the AI-produced patent application to align with these strategies, ensuring that the final document matches the client's vision and goals.    


The AI-driven transformation of patent practices presents both a challenge and an opportunity for law firms. While AI is taking over the once-laborious task of document production, the need for a human touch, accuracy, legal expertise, and personalized service remains. Quality Control and Supervision of AI-produced patent documents can serve as an essential service and a new revenue stream for law firms navigating this new landscape.    

In the face of rapid technological advancements, law firms that can adapt and leverage their unique human skills stand to gain. By embracing QC&S, firms can ensure that they continue to provide high-value services that cater to the nuanced needs of their clients, thereby sustaining and even growing in the rapidly changing world of patent law.    

Experience the power of IP Elevated™

From invention harvesting and vetting to inventor interviews and application preparation, the future of patent portfolio development is coming.